Hey Brian I'd say go with what works for you. Go back. Fitting your wedges is very important as you have learned and it's costing you [strokes] You are maintaining a 4* gap; however you've strengthened your clubs by 2* - not sure if you kept the same grinds or if those are different as well. I have several wedges and will bag different ones depending on conditions. Lofts on the bottom end will be same but the bounce is different to consider turf/sand interaction. 50.08F, 50.12F, 54M, 58M, 58K I used to play PW(47*) 52, 56 and 60. I went to PW (47), 50, 54, 58 and it works much better for me and by adding in the different grinds has avoided other club:turf issues Play Well S.